Independent Detective Case File
Sarah T Szafranski
HomicideChicago, Cook, Illinois, USA
Overview
🔹 What happened — February 2, 2008
On the morning of February 2, 2008, a man posing as a delivery person entered the Lane Bryant women’s clothing store in the Brookside Marketplace in Tinley Park, Illinois (a Chicago suburb). He forced six women—two employees and four customers—into a back room at gunpoint. He tied their hands and then shot all six. Five women, including Jennifer Lynn “Jeni” Van Bishop, were killed execution-style; one woman survived by playing dead after a bullet grazed her neck.
Detailed Case Breakdown
This is a unique case that consisted of 5 people who tragically lost their lives in a multiple homicide that is still onging:
Other victims (and links to their pages):
Carrie Chiuso
Rhoda McFarland
Connie R Woolfolk
Sarah T Szafranski
Jennifer L Bishop
🔹 What happened — February 2, 2008
On the morning of February 2, 2008, a man entered the Lane Bryant women’s clothing store in the Brookside Marketplace in Tinley Park, Illinois (a Chicago suburb) claiming to be a delivery person. He forced six women — two employees and four customers — into a back room at gunpoint. He tied their hands and then shot all six. Five women, including Sarah T. Szafranski, were killed execution-style; one woman survived by playing dead after a bullet grazed her neck.
🔹 Sarah T. Szafranski
– Name: Sarah T. Szafranski, age 26, of Tinley Park, Illinois.
– She was one of the five women murdered in the Lane Bryant shooting.
– Sarah was remembered by family and friends as a caring and ambitious young woman with a bright future ahead.
– At the time of the attack, she had stopped in the store to shop and was known locally for her involvement in community activities.
– Sarah was engaged and looking forward to starting her life with her fiancé.
🔹 The Crime
– The shooter tied up the victims, sexually assaulted them, and then shot them in the back of the head.
– He fled the scene before police arrived, and the case quickly became a major investigation in the Chicago area.
– The lone survivor helped police develop a description that was later turned into a composite sketch of the suspect.
🔹 Investigation and Status
– Despite thousands of tips and evidence collected, including the suspect’s voice recorded on a brief 911 call placed by one of the women inside the store, no suspect has ever been arrested.
– Investigators have released various sketches and 3D composite images of the suspect over the years in hopes of generating new leads.
– A reward has been offered for information leading to an arrest, and police continue to treat the case as active.
– The motive remains unclear, though police originally believed it began as an armed robbery that escalated into sexual assault and murder.
🔹 Legacy
Sarah and the other four women — Carrie Chiuso, Rhoda McFarland, Connie Woolfolk, and Jennifer Bishop — are remembered annually by their communities, and the case remains one of the most notorious unsolved mass murders in the region.
🕵️♂️ Additional Info
There’s a reward of up to $100,000 for information leading to an arrest in this case.
Authorities have released sketches and an audio snippet of the suspect’s voice from the original 911 call on the Tinley Park police website to help generate new leads.
——————————————-
Facebook Post:
Someone knows something.
It’s been 18 years since five women were murdered inside a suburban Lane Bryant store. The case remains unsolved.
The victims were Carrie Chiuso, Rhoda McFarland, Connie R. Woolfolk, Sarah T. Szafranski, and Jennifer L. Bishop.


February 2nd, 2008, Tinley Park Lane Bryant Crime Scene- Photo Courtesy of the Chicago Tribune
Social Media, News and Case Links:
Facebook Group: Carrie’s Unsolved Case Post
ABC 7 Chicago: Lane Bryant Murders
Fox News: 3D Sketch of Suspect In Murders
Find a Grave: Virtual Cemetery for all 5 Victims
Wikipedia: Lane Bryant Shooting
American Crime Journal: Lane Bryant Murders
Contact Information:
| Agency / Reference | Contact |
|---|---|
| Tinley Park Police Department Tip Hotline: | (708) 444-5394 |
| Email: | lanebryant.tipline@tinleypark.org |
Event Timeline Graph
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| February 2, 2008 – Around 10:00 a.m. | Lane Bryant store opens at Brookside Marketplace in Tinley Park, Illinois. |
| Shortly after opening | A man posing as a delivery driver enters the store. |
| Approximately 10:15 a.m. | Employees realize the man is not a delivery worker. He pulls a handgun and takes employees and customers hostage. |
| Minutes later | Additional customers, including Sarah T. Szafranski, enter the store and are forced into the stockroom. |
| Approximately 10:30 a.m. | Store manager Rhoda McFarland secretly calls 911 using a Bluetooth headset. The suspect’s voice is captured before the call disconnects. |
| Shortly afterward | The gunman shoots six women. Sarah Szafranski and four others are killed. One employee survives by pretending to be dead. |
| February 2008 | Massive multi-agency investigation begins involving Tinley Park Police, FBI, Illinois State Police, and regional task forces. |
| Following years | Thousands of leads are investigated, forensic evidence is repeatedly reviewed, and composite sketches and audio recordings are released. |
| 2022 | Investigators release updated digital and 3D suspect renderings while emphasizing the case remains active. (Uncovered) |
| 2024–2026 | Authorities continue reviewing evidence using modern forensic techniques. The investigation remains open, and a $100,000 reward is still offered for information leading to an arrest and conviction. (Uncovered) |
Submit a Tip & Stay Updated
Share Information
Every tip matters. Information, memories, photographs, timelines, or small details may help bring attention back to a case.
Contact Law Enforcement First
If your information could assist an active investigation, please contact the investigating agency directly first. Law enforcement can immediately evaluate credible information and take action when needed.
Information submitted through this website may be reviewed, documented, or shared publicly, but Independent Detective cannot investigate or respond the way authorities can.
What You Can Share
You may share information, memories, photographs, links, observations, corrections, or details you believe may be connected to a case.
Even something that seems insignificant could help move an investigation forward.
Respectful Discussion
Thoughts and theories are welcome, but please remain respectful.
Avoid identifying, accusing, or targeting individuals without supporting evidence.
Stay Connected
Subscribe free to receive notifications when new cases are added to the archive, important case developments occur, or new website features become available.
We respect your inbox and only send occasional updates that we believe are important to the community. You may unsubscribe at any time.
Map Location
Chicago, Illinois
On February 2, 2008
The marker represents an approximate location.
Lane Bryant women’s clothing store in the Brookside Marketplace in Tinley Park was closed and replaced with T.J. Maxx
Location disclaimer: This map may identify only the general city or surrounding area. It should not be interpreted as the exact location where the homicide occurred, where a person went missing, or where any other case event took place unless an exact location has been independently confirmed and entered.
Case Correction Report
See something wrong? Let us know.
This form is for correcting information displayed on Independent Detective. If you have new evidence or information about the investigation itself, please use Submit Evidence instead.
Leave a Reply