Overview

Last Seen: October 2016
Location: Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Age When Missing: 31
Status: Missing
NamUs #: MP36915

Main circumstances: Jamie disappeared from Milwaukee in October 2016. Authorities have released very few details explaining the circumstances leading up to her disappearance. Wisconsin authorities currently use October 20 as her missing date, while an earlier Milwaukee news report identified October 15 and the 900 block of South 19th Street as the location where she was last seen.

There is no reliable public information establishing that Jamie was the victim of a homicide. Her case remains publicly listed as a missing-person investigation.

Detailed Case Breakdown

Jamie Lee Hoaglan Missing From Milwaukee, Wisconsin Since 2016: What We Know About Her Disappearance

Jamie Lee Hoaglan was 31 years old when she disappeared from Milwaukee, Wisconsin, in October 2016. Nearly a decade later, her whereabouts remain unknown, and she continues to be listed as a long-term missing person by the Milwaukee Police Department and Wisconsin authorities.

The Wisconsin Department of Justice currently lists Jamie’s official missing date as October 20, 2016. An earlier news report, however, stated that she was last seen on October 15, 2016, in the 900 block of South 19th Street in Milwaukee. The difference between the dates remains present in publicly available records.

Very Brief Case Summary

Last Seen: October 2016
Location: Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Age When Missing: 31
Status: Missing
NamUs #: MP36915

Main circumstances: Jamie disappeared from Milwaukee in October 2016. Authorities have released very few details explaining the circumstances leading up to her disappearance. Wisconsin authorities currently use October 20 as her missing date, while an earlier Milwaukee news report identified October 15 and the 900 block of South 19th Street as the location where she was last seen.

There is no reliable public information establishing that Jamie was the victim of a homicide. Her case remains publicly listed as a missing-person investigation.

The Disappearance of Jamie Lee Hoaglan

Jamie was 31 when she vanished in Milwaukee. The Wisconsin Department of Justice describes her as a white woman who stood approximately 5 feet 7 inches tall and weighed about 125 pounds. She had red or auburn hair and hazel eyes at the time of her disappearance.

The state’s current missing-person listing says Jamie was last seen on October 20, 2016, in Milwaukee and states simply that her whereabouts are unknown.

Publicly available information about what happened immediately before or after Jamie disappeared is unusually limited. Authorities have not publicly provided a detailed account of where she was going, who she may have been with, what she was wearing, or what circumstances initially caused concern about her whereabouts.

Conflicting Dates in Jamie Hoaglan’s Case

One detail that deserves particular attention is the discrepancy concerning Jamie’s last known date.

The Wisconsin Department of Justice lists Jamie as missing since October 20, 2016. The state’s updated missing-person poster also uses October 20.

However, WISN 12 reported in October 2017 that Jamie had last been seen on October 15, 2016, in the 900 block of South 19th Street in Milwaukee.

NamUs-derived listings have also historically reflected October 15 as the last-seen date.

Because the official Wisconsin listing currently uses October 20, that is the date generally associated with her case today. However, October 15 should not be disregarded when reviewing older information, potential witness memories, photographs, messages, surveillance footage, or other records from the period surrounding her disappearance.

Search for Jamie

By October 2017, Jamie had been missing for more than a year. Milwaukee police continued asking the public for information that could help locate her.

Her disappearance did not disappear from official records as the years passed. Wisconsin’s Clearinghouse for Missing & Exploited Children & Adults continued distributing Jamie’s information, and an updated state missing-person poster identified her NamUs case as MP36915.

Jamie also remains included on the Milwaukee Police Department’s current public list of long-term missing people.

Latest Publicly Available Case Information

As of September 2026, Jamie remains publicly listed by both the Wisconsin Department of Justice and Milwaukee Police Department as missing.

The Wisconsin Department of Justice currently lists her age as 41 and continues to state that her whereabouts are unknown. Milwaukee Police also continue to include Jamie among the department’s long-term missing persons.

No credible publicly available law-enforcement announcement located for this article reports that Jamie has been found, identifies a suspect, announces an arrest, or states that investigators have officially determined she was the victim of homicide.

That distinction is important. The absence of publicly released investigative details does not reveal what information investigators may possess internally, but publicly Jamie’s case remains an unresolved missing-person investigation.

Why the Date Discrepancy Matters

The difference between October 15 and October 20 represents a five-day period that could potentially matter when people search their memories or old records.

Someone who lived, worked, drove, shopped, or socialized around Milwaukee during that period may remember something that did not initially appear important. Old photographs, messages, social-media activity, receipts, calendars, or other records from October 15 through October 20, 2016, could potentially help establish a clearer timeline.

Any information believed to relate to Jamie’s disappearance should be provided directly to law enforcement rather than treated as established fact online.

Jamie Hoaglan’s Description

At the time she went missing, Jamie was described as 31 years old, approximately 5 feet 7 inches tall and 125 pounds. She is white, with red or auburn hair and hazel eyes.

Her NamUs identifier is MP36915.

Jamie would now be in her early 40s, meaning her appearance may have changed considerably since the photographs circulated when she first disappeared.

How to Help

Anyone with information about Jamie Lee Hoaglan’s disappearance or whereabouts is encouraged to contact the Milwaukee Police Department at 414-935-7405. Milwaukee Police also publishes 414-933-4444 as a number for information concerning missing persons.

Information may also be provided to the Wisconsin Clearinghouse for Missing & Exploited Children & Adults at 1-800-843-4673 (1-800-THE-HOPE).

Even information that appears minor could help investigators establish where Jamie was, whom she encountered, or what occurred during the days surrounding her disappearance.