Overview

On June 7, 1992, Sherrill Elizabeth Levitt, age 47, vanished from her Springfield, Missouri home alongside her daughter Suzanne “Suzie” Streeter, age 19, and Suzie’s friend Stacy Kathleen McCall, age 18. Their disappearance—famously known as “The Springfield Three”—remains one of the most baffling and unresolved missing persons cases in U.S. history.

Detailed Case Breakdown

There were 3 Missing Persons Linked to this Case:

Stacey McCall
Suzanne Streeter
Sherrill Levitt

The Mysterious Disappearance of Stacy Kathleen McCall: The Springfield Three Case

On June 7, 1992, 18‑year‑old Stacy Kathleen McCall vanished from her home in Springfield, Missouri, along with two others — a disappearance that remains unsolved more than three decades later. McCall had just graduated from Kickapoo High School the day before and was spending time with friends in celebration when she disappeared without a trace.

The case, widely known among investigators and true crime communities as The Springfield Three, involves McCall, her close friend 19‑year‑old Suzanne “Suzie” Streeter, and Streeter’s 47‑year‑old mother Sherrill Elizabeth Levitt. All three were together the night before they vanished, but on the morning of June 7, police were called after no one answered the door — and the trio could not be found.

Eerie Details at the Scene

When authorities arrived at Levitt’s home at 1717 E. Delmar Street, they encountered an unsettling scene:

– Cars, purses, keys, and personal belongings were still inside the house.
– The family dog had been left behind.
– There were no clear signs of a struggle, although a porch light globe was broken.
– A message left on the answering machine that could have been a vital clue was inadvertently erased by police.
– Phones reportedly rang repeatedly with a man’s voice making disturbing remarks when friends visited the residence the next day, but these recordings were never definitively linked to the case.

The lack of typical evidence — such as blood, torn clothing, or a missing person’s belongings — has made the case especially perplexing to investigators and armchair detectives alike.

Investigation And Leads

Despite thousands of tips from the public over the years and the involvement of several law enforcement agencies, including the Springfield Police Department and the FBI, the whereabouts of McCall, Streeter, and Levitt remain unknown. As of 2026, no confirmed charges or arrests have been made in connection with the disappearances.

Some notable developments in the investigation include:

– 1997: Convicted kidnapper Robert Craig Cox claimed knowledge of the women’s fate and alleged they had been murdered. However, investigators have determined Cox lacks credibility, and no evidence has linked him to the case.
– Efforts to raise reward funds: Family members, including McCall’s relatives, have attempted to increase the reward amount decades after the disappearance in hopes of encouraging new leads.
– Cold Case Status: The case is officially listed as unsolved, and periodically renewed public interest through media, podcasts, and anniversaries continues to keep attention on this haunting mystery.

Why the Case Still Resonates

The Springfield Three disappearance remains one of the most baffling cold cases in American true crime history precisely because three people seemed to vanish without any physical evidence of what happened to them. The unanswered questions — from the broken porch light to the erased answering machine message — have left investigators and the public searching for clues for over 30 years.

Family members, friends, and law enforcement continue to hope that future advances in forensic science or a new piece of credible information might finally unlock what happened the night Stacy McCall and the others disappeared.
———————————————

Facebook Post:

Three women vanished from one home in Springfield, Missouri.
No forced entry. No obvious struggle. No trace.

On the night of June 6, 1992, Suzanne Streeter and Stacey McCall spent the evening celebrating their high school graduation. Late that night, plans changed, and they returned to Suzanne’s home on Delmar Street, where her mother, Sherrill Levitt, was already home.

By morning, all three women were gone.

Their cars were still parked outside. Their purses were inside the house, containing cash, IDs, and personal items they would not have left behind. The television was on. Their dog was unharmed. There were no signs of a struggle.

Outside, a porch light globe had been broken, but investigators were never able to determine when it happened or if it was related.

In the early hours after friends arrived to check on them, the home was not immediately secured as a crime scene. Voicemail messages were erased. Glass was cleaned up. By the time police fully took control, potential evidence may already have been lost.

Investigators ruled out a voluntary disappearance. None of the women took money, clothing, or vehicles. All had future plans.

One question still lingers decades later: how did three adults leave a home together without resistance?

Authorities have suggested coercion, familiarity, or the presence of a weapon, but no theory has ever been proven. No suspects have been publicly named. No confirmed physical evidence has ever been recovered.

More than thirty years later, the Springfield Three remain missing.