Independent Detective Case File

Amy Elizabeth Davis

Suspected Homicide

Edmond, Oklahoma, Oklahoma, USA

Case Number #174
Date of Incident June 11, 2008
Age 18 DOB: 05/02/1988
Type of Case Suspected Homicide
Case Entry July 15, 2026
Last Updated July 20, 2026
Overview


Sara Ebersole, 28, went missing in Reddick, Florida, on March 2-3, 2023. She was last seen with Tyrone Morman, a person of interest in the case. Despite extensive searches and a $35,000 reward for information, no sightings have emerged. Authorities continue to seek public assistance in locating her.

– Sara Ebersole, 28, was reported missing after last being seen on March 2–3, 2023 in Reddick, Marion County, Florida.

– She was seen at a 24-hour convenience store and then taken to a residence along U.S. Highway 441.

– Shortly after midnight, she left that location with a man named Tyrone Morman, who is now considered a person of interest.


For nearly 17 years, the young woman known only as the “Croft & Barrow Jane Doe” remained one of Oklahoma’s most heartbreaking unidentified persons cases. Found in Oklahoma City in November 2008, investigators were unable to determine who she was despite extensive forensic work, facial reconstructions, and public appeals.

In 2026, advances in forensic genetic genealogy finally restored her identity. The woman was identified as Amy Elizabeth Davis, an Oklahoma native who disappeared in 2008 after leaving home as a young adult. While investigators now know her name, the circumstances surrounding her death remain unanswered.

Who Was Amy Elizabeth Davis?

Amy Elizabeth Davis was born on May 2, 1988, and was adopted as a child by an Oklahoma family. According to information released following her identification, she left home around age 18 and was believed to have been living in the Oklahoma City area.

Family members reportedly attempted to report her missing in 2008. Because she was legally an adult and believed to be living independently, the case did not initially receive the level of investigation often associated with missing juveniles. Years later, members of Amy’s biological family began searching for her after learning more about her adoption history, eventually leading to a new missing persons report and DNA comparison that resulted in her identification.

Discovery of the Remains

On November 5, 2008, utility workers replacing a power pole in the 300 block of Southwest 10th Street in Oklahoma City discovered partial skeletal human remains.

Investigators estimated the victim was a young woman between 17 and 23 years old. Because she wore distinctive black Croft & Barrow slip-on shoes, she became widely known as the “Croft & Barrow Jane Doe.”

Despite extensive forensic examinations, investigators were unable to determine how she died. The official cause and manner of death remain undetermined, leaving open the possibility that additional evidence could change the classification in the future.

Years Without a Name

For more than a decade, Amy’s case appeared on numerous unidentified persons databases.

Investigators created forensic facial reconstructions, compared missing persons reports nationwide, and entered her DNA into national databases. None of those efforts produced a match.

The breakthrough came after relatives from Amy’s biological family began researching her disappearance and submitted DNA that ultimately confirmed her identity through forensic genetic genealogy. The identification was publicly announced in 2026.

Current Status of the Investigation

Although Amy Elizabeth Davis has now been identified, her death remains unsolved.

Authorities have not announced any suspects, arrests, or homicide determination. The official cause of death is still listed as undetermined while investigators continue reviewing information about Amy’s life, movements during 2008, and anyone who may have known her during her final months.

Investigators continue to encourage anyone who knew Amy or has information about her disappearance or death to contact authorities. Even seemingly minor details from 2008 may help establish a timeline or identify individuals she encountered before her death..

————————————————
Facebook Post:
It has been 109 days since the confirmation of Amy’s remains. The Oklahoma medical examiners office is still investigating so at this time we don’t have a cause of death we are still waiting on them to close out her report, it’s taken longer because unfortunately all they had were bones to test from. I’ve been in communication with a family assistant coordinator at the ME office and I’m waiting on an updated timeline. We are STILL searching for answers of what happened to Amy. I have found a few people who knew Amy/knew of her but unfortunately every direction I’m lead in hasn’t given me answers and a lot of the people she was around are either deceased or in prison. If you have any information please reach out to me. Amy’s remains were found in Oklahoma in 2008.

AgencyRoleContact Information
Oklahoma Office of the Chief Medical ExaminerIdentification and forensic investigation(405) 239-7141 (The Cold Cases)
Oklahoma City Police Department – Cold Case UnitInvestigation into Amy’s deathNon-Emergency: (405) 231-2121
Oklahoma State Bureau of Investigation (OSBI)Tips related to unsolved casesTips: 1-800-522-8017 or submit through the OSBI Tip Line
DateEvent
May 2, 1988Amy Elizabeth Davis is born.
Around 2006–2008Leaves home as a young adult and is believed to have been living in the Oklahoma City area.
Around June 11, 2008Last known timeframe Amy was reportedly seen alive. (Unidentified Wiki)
November 5, 2008Partial skeletal remains discovered by utility workers in Oklahoma City.
2008Investigators open an unidentified persons investigation; victim becomes known as the “Croft & Barrow Jane Doe.”
2011Forensic facial reconstruction released to help identify the victim.
2008–2025DNA comparisons, forensic reviews, and public appeals fail to identify the victim.
January 2026Amy’s biological family files a missing persons report after reconnecting family history. (Unidentified Wiki)
March 2026DNA confirms the victim is Amy Elizabeth Davis. Identity publicly announced. (The Cold Cases)
PresentInvestigation into Amy’s death remains active; cause of death is still undetermined. (The Cold Cases)

Share Information

Every tip matters. Information, memories, photographs, timelines, or small details may help bring attention back to a case.

Contact Law Enforcement First

If your information could assist an active investigation, please contact the investigating agency directly first. Law enforcement can immediately evaluate credible information and take action when needed.

Information submitted through this website may be reviewed, documented, or shared publicly, but Independent Detective cannot investigate or respond the way authorities can.

What You Can Share

You may share information, memories, photographs, links, observations, corrections, or details you believe may be connected to a case.

Even something that seems insignificant could help move an investigation forward.

Respectful Discussion

Thoughts and theories are welcome, but please remain respectful.

Avoid identifying, accusing, or targeting individuals without supporting evidence.

Stay Connected

Subscribe free to receive notifications when new cases are added to the archive, important case developments occur, or new website features become available.

We respect your inbox and only send occasional updates that we believe are important to the community. You may unsubscribe at any time.

Leave a Reply

Map Location

Edmond, Oklahoma

On June 11, 2008

Location disclaimer: This map may identify only the general city or surrounding area. It should not be interpreted as the exact location where the homicide occurred, where a person went missing, or where any other case event took place unless an exact location has been independently confirmed and entered.

0 researchers are following this case